Shopify vs. WooCommerce Cost: Should You Stay or Switch?

Compare the next 12 months of costs on both platforms, including labor, paid apps, payment fees, and the one-time cost to move.

StoreBuild Works · · 4 min read

If your WooCommerce store already works, compare the next 12 months on both platforms. A monthly Shopify plan is easy to price. The harder question is whether it changes the amount you spend on maintenance, paid extensions, processing, and staff time. Add the one-time cost of moving before you decide.

Key takeaways

  • Model both options at the same sales, order volume, and business requirements.
  • Count internal maintenance time once. Include time spent on Shopify apps and operations too.
  • Check payment eligibility and test your critical WooCommerce workflows before paying for a move.

Build two annual cost models

WooCommerce’s core platform has no platform subscription fee. Hosting, commercial extensions, maintenance, and payment processing can still add up. Shopify bundles hosted commerce infrastructure into a subscription. Its U.S. Basic plan was listed at $39 per month on monthly billing and $29 per month equivalent on annual billing as of November 18, 2026. Check the current terms where your business operates. WooCommerce pricing · Shopify pricing

CostStaying on WooCommerceMoving to Shopify
Base software and hostingHosting, backups or security services where needed, premium extensions.Shopify plan, required apps, and any gateway-related fees.
MaintenanceUpdates, testing, plugin conflicts, and developer support.Theme and app upkeep, integrations, and contract support.
First-year project workPlanned redesigns, hosting changes, or fixes you would do anyway.Data migration, storefront rebuild, redirects, app setup, and training.
Order-level costsProcessing, currency fees, chargebacks, and provider terms.Processing, applicable third-party transaction fees, currency and provider terms.
Compare what your business actually uses on both platforms.

Use annual equivalents consistently. If a subscription bills annually, record the upfront cash payment even if your spreadsheet spreads it over 12 months. Use the same order volumes and target currencies for payment comparisons. When an app has a usage limit, price the tier you will actually use at your current order volume.

Work through a break-even example

Assume an existing store pays $35 per month for hosting, $45 per month equivalent for extensions, and $180 per month for maintenance. Its ongoing cost is $260 per month. A proposed Shopify setup costs $39 for Basic, $55 for apps, and $75 for ongoing support, totaling $169 per month before payment fees. Those are hypothetical operating inputs aside from the stated Shopify plan rate.

MeasureStaySwitch
Operating cost per month$260$169
Operating cost for 12 months$3,120$2,028
One-time move$0$2,000
First-year total$3,120$4,028
Illustrative monthly saving after the move—$91
Illustrative scenario. Domain fees, payment costs, taxes, and sales are held outside the example.

With $91 a month in savings, a $2,000 move takes about 22 months to recover before any payment fee differences. Your first-year cost is $908 higher in this example. If your WooCommerce setup already runs with very little support or your Shopify app stack is bigger, the gap could narrow or reverse. If a store is costly to run, write down the specific hours and invoices you think will fall.

Check payment fees against actual volume. At $30,000 in monthly eligible sales, a 0.3 percentage-point difference equals $90 per month before fixed per-order charges. That would almost erase the illustrative $91 saving. The rate difference here is hypothetical. Use both providers’ terms, including any platform transaction fee that applies to your gateway.

Check which functions actually need to move

  • Recreate your highest-value store workflow in a test setup, such as a subscription renewal, bundle discount, tax treatment, or fulfillment integration.
  • Check your ability to take payments in your entity’s country. Confirm approval steps, payout accounts, and supported currencies with the provider.
  • Inventory product options and custom fields, and test a product with the hardest option combinations.
  • Separate a platform problem from a storefront problem. Product copy, shipping rules, and checkout messaging may be cheaper to fix where you are.

When staying or switching makes sense

Stay on WooCommerce when your store is stable, your team is comfortable maintaining it, and a critical feature already works well there. Switch when you want a hosted commerce workflow, you’ve identified replacements for must-have features, and the benefits justify both the operating costs and the move. For each reason to switch, specify how you would measure the result after launch.

If you’re leaning toward a move, get a scoped migration quote and make a small feasibility test part of the proposal. If you’re setting up a new store, use the first-year setup budget instead. To review an existing WooCommerce catalog and its requirements, see our migration service.

Frequently asked questions

Which platform is cheaper for a small store?

Compare your hosting and paid extensions with Shopify’s subscription and likely apps. Then add the value of maintenance time and any difference in payment fees. A small store can come out ahead on either platform.

How should I budget for SEO during the move?

Set aside time for a URL inventory, destination mapping, redirect checks, and monitoring after launch. Ask the provider to write those items into the quote so you can compare them.